The good pregnant woman
>> Friday, August 28, 2009
I've already been boning up on the good mom/bad mom debate. I'm already preparing to enter the battle in sixish months, armed and ready.
Maybe it's because I wasn't planning this whole thing, but I wasn't at all prepared for the world of preggo judgment I've been thrust into. I've had to put together makeshift armor without giving myself time to strategize or lift weights or sharpen my swords. Four months in, though (three conscious ones), I've at least been able to put up a temporary defense. I've at least begun to size up my enemy and recognize her strengths and weaknesses.
I've come to realize there are really three types of pregnant women. There's the small minority, the women who truly don't give a shit about the wellbeing of their babies or themselves. I'm talking about the women who snort coke, shoot up heroine, smoke crack, all the while patting their bellies to say hello. And then there's the polar opposite, the women who have pocket-size copies of What to Expect When You're Expecting in their Marc Jacobs purses, who avoid soft cheese and tuna fish like the plague, who roll their eyes at the pregnant women who say they "have" to drink coffee, who applaud their superior willpower over these monsters, who troll BabyCenter.com waiting to pounce on anyone who dares make a "Help Me Quit Smoking!" post.
And then there's me. The woman who easily gave up her crack addiction (joke), who had to work REALLY hard to quit smoking, who still drinks some coffee and Diet Coke, who lived with a massive acne outbreak for about three weeks before giving in and using benzoyl peroxide, who regularly eats deli meat, sometimes even without heating it to steaming hot in the microwave, who just ate a tuna fish sandwich because I really wanted one.
Sometimes I feel guilty for the fact that I'm not the perfect pregnant woman.
I remember when I first found out and was trying really hard to quit smoking, I kept thinking about this girl at my work and her story of kicking the habit. She told me she was (like me) one of those people who actually loved smoking, who had no desire to quit. And then she got pregnant, she said, and she quit just like that (to this she snapped her manicured fingers). The urge to smoke was magically gone, she said, the second she saw that positive sign on the pregnancy test.
Every time I gave in during those first few days, I'd think about her and let the guilt wash over me. She has pictures of her adorable daughter all over her desk. She talks about nothing but that child. She loves her enough to give up smoking, just like that.
And then, two weeks ago, I found out she lied. Talking to one of her clothes friends at work about how I quit smoking (she was in the middle of trying, too), she let it slip just how hard it had been for the snapping-her-fingers girl, how she had dragged her on secret smoking breaks daily until she started showing and could no longer keep up the ruse.
I've worried from the begininning that I'm destined to be a "bad mom." Apparently, I care more about myself than my child, because I'd rather eat tuna fish if I want it or use benzoyl peroxide face wash (something my doc okayed, by the way), despite the tinylittleminiscule risk, all to satisfy my selfish desires.
The preggo police on Baby Center would have me think so, anyway.
I remember one woman who made a post on there just to villify another pregnant woman she'd seen smoking in her car. And then the hormental hordes lined up to add their two cents, calling her nothing short of Osama Bin Laden's evil twin.
I just don't--can't--really work like that. Yeah, it might look a tad irresponsible, the big 'ole pregnant woman puffing away in her car. But if you used to be a smoker, you wouldn't automatically send her to the dogs. Maybe she DID quit. Maybe this is her first cigarette in months, in which case, you should be CONGRATULATING her on making it this far. Maybe something terrible just happened to her, and she fell into a moment of weakness. Maybe her dog just died. Maybe she doesn't care as much as you, in which case, thank god you don't have to be her! Maybe you should be watching the road instead of staring at the pregnant woman in the car next to you, because isn't that what a perfect pregnant woman would do? Are you wearing your seatbelt? Are your hands at ten and two??
All I know is that quitting smoking was hard enough. I already feel like a slave to this baby. I already have put its needs first--but it's not your (the world's) place to justify what those needs are. That responsibility belongs to me. And my doctor. And Google.
Pregnancy, like parenting, like life, isn't so black and white. And it might do the judgmental, perfect mothers-to-be in the world some good to recognize the innumerable grays.
10 comments:
I just read the full contents on your blog; love your writing and honesty:) I'll be back daily even if you aren't;)
Your story of the smoking co-worker is probably indicative of all the other pregnant nazis on baby center. They want to vilify you or someone else so they don't feel so guilty about their own transgressions. Do you know many people who got sick from eating lunch meat or tuna? Why do people suddenly think it will happen to them once they get pregnant?
The worst thing is that half the pregnancy books on the market endorse this ascetic mentality, to the point of making irresponsible and absurd recommendations. One book I made the mistake of buying stated that I need to give up my cats if I don't have anyone else to scoop their litter box, based on the astronomically low chance that I could contract toxoplasmosis (which I'm probably already immune to, having grown up with outdoor cats)! The stupid book also said that I wouldn't be able to eat or drink anything during labor, which is some sort of irrational throwback to an isolated, unresearched incident that occurred in the 1930s. That tuna sandwich you ate will just make your fetus stronger, Sarah! A little mercury won't make him/her foam at the mouth. Heck, I got my doctor to okay occasional sushi for me, as long as I know and trust the restaurant. I read an article published in the London Daily Mail that suggested to me that Europeans are still able to accept that pregnant women should have autonomy, and not be treated like babies. I'm ready to move to London! -Aubrey
Let me start by saying i have enjoyed you blog since reading a post on Momversations. but this post has me commenting...
im a 'pregnant nazi' on BBC, HOWERVER, i was a smoker. ive quit with all 3 of my pregnancies. for the greater good of the BABY. sure i picked the bad habit back up after* the first 2, but my hope is that i wont cave into that weakness a third time-and i will be able to call myself a quitter for life!
there are a million excuses people give Pro and Con.
but ive been a smoker for 15 years, so im proof that it can be done. im no super hero for doing it. its mind over matter. and i really cant sympathize with those that say they cant do it. then turn around and post those threads about how guilty they feel, then go on to list the bazillion excuses there are.
i dont sit and feel superior becasue* i can do it-but others cant. but im tired of hearing the same story...i just cant, i just cant. its a bogus cop-out. cuz they all can. and seriously-the ladies who claim their docs say not to stress over it-cuz the quitting itself could be harmful to the fetus?! they should all be losing licenses.
one more thing.
**Emily August 30, 2009 6:52 AM (wrote):..."Do you know many people who got sick from eating lunch meat or tuna? Why do people suddenly think it will happen to them once they get pregnant?"**
i just have to add that its statements like these that have the "nazis" on BBC so adament about these specific subjects. they expect factual statements, and if they are not set up correctly then its a total bitchfest thread.
a BBC'er would correct this statement by saying things like- 'its not about how many people get sick from lunch meat-its the fact that you cant* know if your lunch meat has listeria in it-and the fetus can become very ill-regardless* of weather they themselves got sick. it passes through the placenta, and you have no way of knowing it. therefore its your choice to make-but at least know the facts* before making a statement someone else can come and read and take for face value. LISTERIA is not* a deathly illness if your not pregnant-that is why it matters if you ARE pregnant. To each their own, just be armed with the facts.
end rant-thank you-sorry for doing it on your blog. i really do enjoy your writings about your journey!
Hmmm...good thing I didn't post on Baby Center then (is that what you are using BBC to stand for? Because I thought you were talking about the British Broadcasting Corporation.). It's also good that I got my facts from doctors and midwives while pregnant and not random people online and that I understand statistics.
/I co-sleep with a 6 month old, my husband and two cats, put baby formula in the microwave, and still use one of those baby walker things. Someone call CPS.
its responses like that - that get people into name calling and heated arguments. no one gives a shit about your co sleeping and microwaving of formula. those things have NOTHING to do with the risk of smoking while pregnant, and listeria. but closed minded people will continue to respond as you did. just as im sure you will have something else to say again about this comment.
I did not mean to call all people on baby center nazi, and I apologize that I hurt your feelings. I should have been more clear. I think the people who Sarah mentioned, who attack others who are asking for advice on how to quit smoking are nasty people.
Congratulations for quitting smoking. I am saying this to illustrate one of my points that people here do "give a shit" about what other people post. Perhaps I am incorrect. If that is the case, Sarah can opt out of allowing comments.
No, cosleeping and microwaving formula have nothing to do with listeria or smoking and I never suggested they did. They were mentioned to underline a different point--that people need to think for themselves and do research for themselves and not be bullied into thinking a certain way by anonymous people online (this is not a jab at anyone here posting without an id. This is to refer to anyone you meet online who you will not meet in real life and whose credentials you don't know). It's ironic then that you suggested I was close minded, as my whole point is to think for yourself. (Except maybe I am close minded about smoking in thinking it is bad for mommy, baby, and everyone around them.)
Why did you post originally? Was it just to call Sarah a "cop-out" because you were able to quit smoking whereas she is having trouble and to self-identify yourself as a pregnant nazi? Why tell me what people at babycenter will think? I don't care, that's why I don't go there. From Sarah's description, they seem to post without compassion or respect for differences. I choose to post here because it is unlike baby center. Sarah is very unlike most pregnant people and mom's I've met in real life. And if you misunderstanding others, telling people you don't care about their lives, and posting what you described to begin a "total bitchfest" is any indication of what goes on there, I have no interest in it.
what i said,
(c&p'ed) ::i dont sit and feel superior because* i can do it-but others cant. but im tired of hearing the same story...i just cant, i just cant. its a bogus cop-out
what you said, (also c&p'ed):: Why did you post originally? Was it just to call Sarah a "cop-out" because you were able to quit smoking whereas she is having trouble and to self-identify yourself as a pregnant nazi?
my reply: i DID NOT in any of my post call out Sarah. i dont specifically remember her writing that she had picked the habit back up. if she did, it was lost on me. i was still under the impression she had quit. The reason i originally posted is because she DID* say something to the effect-that the women who are nasty on BabyCenter clearly have no experience with smoking or they wouldnt have such a harsh opinion. i posted because its simply not true-I WAS a smoker and for 15 years, and STILL feel as strongly as those* women do weather they have smoked or not. i have only been a NONsmoker since March-FOR MY BABY. NO ONE knows if i'll pick it back up-but my point is i had the willpower and used NO excuses-for the health of my BABY. and i still have no sympathy for those who post threads on babycenter complaining about the entire subject.
AllThe.StarsAreMine
"whether" not "weather"
Sarah, sorry to say, it looks like you are going to have to go live in a vacuum for the next 5 months, because that's the only way to be sure that you don't expose your fetus to anything harmful. Geez, didn't you know that that is what women have been doing for the 30,000 years that anatomically modern humans have existed on this planet? I mean really, how else could civilization have continued to thrive if fetuses had ever been exposed to any sort of toxin? Certainly an impossibility! I'm surprised Baby Center hasn't caught onto this yet. When they do, watch out! It must be a miracle that there are 128 million people thriving in Japan, despite all the rampant tuna (and gasp, RAW tuna) consumed by pregnant women! I can't imagine how the French continue to exist when the nation's women eat unpasteurized cheeses and horror of horrors, drink red wine with dinner and maybe even smoke an occasional cigarette!
Last time I checked, the citizens of countries that don't frighten and bully their population with unscientific horror stories were reproducing healthy babies on the whole. Far more so, in fact, than the good old U.S.of A., where the infant mortality rate is among the highest of all industrialized nations.
Sigh. I think people really need some perspective. Stress really is more harmful to the baby than the infinitesimally small risks associated with the consumption of certain foods and exposure to environmental toxins. That said, I'm glad that you have found the strength to quit smoking. It is, of course, better for your baby that you have. Quitting is clearly easier for some than for others. My husband's own struggles with cigarettes are evidence of that. It's a shame that those who do have an easier time of it lack empathy for those whose road is tougher. But that's typical, right? It's like when a dirt poor kid grows up, becomes successful, and turns into a rabid Republican. It's a way of saying, "look at what I did with no help from anyone else. What's wrong with you that you can't be like me?"
-Aubrey
I'm sad to tell you that this is just the start. I think mothers are some of the most judgmental creatures on the planet. I try to remind myself that most of it stems from insecurity, but I'll be honest: judgmental moms make me feel bad about myself.
I'm working on a piece about Becoming An Adult and I think part of being an adult means realizing your way of doing things is not the only way. I don't think other moms should do things that way I do - I am flying by the seat of my pants half the time. But I am trying and just because it works for me (or doesn't, as the case may be) doesn't mean you should do it that way.
Thanks for being bold enough to blog about this!
Post a Comment