Child-led Parenting. Or What Just Kinda Happened.

>> Friday, May 28, 2010

Yesterday I had lunch with three other moms. Two have babies three weeks younger than Adelyn. One has a baby who's seven months old. I've talked about that particular baby before. Her name is Ella and her cheeks are infinitely kissable and she hardly ever cries. Now she's developed the ability to say her name, which she does over and over while awake. "El-lalala-la. El-lalala-la." She's adorable.


At lunch we got on the topic of Baby Wise, because these are the kind of things four young moms talk about. Baby habits, formula types, breastfeeding vs. bottlefeeding, being hungover and taking care of your baby, the concern over a baby who doesn't care about rolling over, and, I think, the topic of spray tans made a brief appearance. But mostly we just talked about living as a mother.

One of these women, Ella's mom, works full-time. More than full-time, actually. The other just went back to work, working three days a week. The other goes back to work, working from home, in just a couple of weeks. And then there's me, who is caught somewhere between a former desire to devote herself, all of herself, to being a success and trying to figure out how to be a parent.

I did not expect to be a mom right now. I hope when Adelyn someday, inevitably, reads this she understands that that doesn't mean I'm not extraordinarily grateful for how things have turned out. It just means that I was thrown for a loop. Graduating from college and trying to figure out what to do for a living is confusing enough. Doing this with a baby is a bit more so.

I think--fingers crossed--I'm a couple of weeks away from getting the job I hoped for. It doesn't pay much, but it's for an organization I care deeply about and it would allow me to work from home most of the time. Between two family members who are teachers off for the summer and a great grandma who seems to have an infinite number of baby-tricks up her sleeve--along with the generosity of my mother-in-law's friend who's offered to watch Addy whenever I need her to--I think we can avoid putting Addy in day care.

The job does require a three-day training in Atlanta. I have to figure that out. My mom might come with me and watch Addy while I do the required stuff. But other than that, I think we'll be just fine.

But it brings up, once again, this increasingly-tricky question of creating a routine that is predictable. It doesn't have to be on-the-nose scheduled, but it has to be somewhat smooth, like, knowing that within the next three hours I will have an hour I can devote solely to work. And little Adelyn, God love her, does not like predictability. Our newest schedule involves getting up around four thirty in the morning, eating and playing until she's sleepy again, and then putting her in her swing to nap while mommy snoozes on the couch. I never used to need so much sleep. When I was pregnant, even, I woke up at six on the dot. Now when I hear Addy babbling over the monitor at four, five, six I'm desperate for just one more hour between the sheets. (Sleeping.)

I don't like the idea of Baby Wise. Neither do the other moms I was with yesterday. Ella, her mom told us, has developed a schedule all by herself. And she sticks to it. None of us are fond of forcing a schedule on our babies. I think the experts call this "child-led parenting." I call it trying to find something that works. I can't hold off giving Addy a bottle if she's hungry, a nap if she's tired. My neighbors--who are generally incredibly sweet--told us they used to do everything in their power to keep their daughter awake past six p.m. They'd even sprinkle water on her face if she was drifting off. (This might have been a joke. I hope.) And that meant she started sleeping through the night from the start.

I can't do those things. I've tried--not with the water on the face part--to plan out our day, thinking she'd get another bottle in three hours, then another at noon, then a nap, then so on. It never works for me. I always give in.

Am I setting myself up for disaster later on down the line? Am I raising a child who will get what she wants, when she wants it? Or am I just a proponent of this thing called child-led parenting? I don't know. But I do know that Addy wants another bottle, and I'm going to give it to her.

8 comments:

Rachel,  May 28, 2010 at 8:11 AM  

I once read that under a year old, babies just really need to get what they need when they need it. And that unless it's related to health or safety it's really important to give them what they cry for. It sets up a lifetime feeling of trust in their caregivers...
That said, we had a really difficult time transitioning into the toddler years with our child. We were still in that mode of thinking and it took us a while to realize that setting some boundaries is really important and also contributes to a feeling of trust in caregivers. Most importantly though I think that everyone should consider their own child's temperment and do what makes the most sense for their family and what gets their family to optimal functioning...and that nothing you do now is permanent. You can always try something different if you realize it's not working for your family.
Congratulations on your wedding!

Joel and Jaclyn Richards May 28, 2010 at 9:59 AM  

Hey, it's Joel. I look at it more as Cooperative Parenting. I think, for now, Ella knows what she needs more than I do. She's rather pure when it comes to her wants and needs. Now, later on when she is able to say "Hey Daddy, I need ice cream for breakfast," I will argue with her. But for now, I look at it as her helping me help her. She acclimated to us instead of the other way around. Oh, and in my opinion, Babywise should be retitled Babyfoolish.

Miss M May 28, 2010 at 10:35 AM  

She is still so tiny that a "schedule" can just backfire. It will come to a point when you realize that she has been taking a nap every day at the same time and can look forward to that break because she likes to sleep at that time. Eventually. I think mine started around 6 months. Teeth and colds will ruin this though! One thing is absolutely for sure... nothing is for sure with babies :)

Anonymous,  May 28, 2010 at 12:20 PM  

I love your blog! My daughter is about 4.5 months old and I am in a similar position to you. I read all the books out there and honestly I think the babywhisperer was really helpful. Once I got my daughter on a routine (not a schedule) life became so much easier and she was such a happier baby. Knowing with 95% condifdence that she will be ready for a nap in about 30 min or that when she's cranky it's almost always because she's tierd is wonderful! That being said I think just winging it all day long, feeding your baby to sleep, rocking to sleep etc.. works too, but that can be hard if you don't have the whole day to dedicate to the unpredictability of winging it. I also know moms who did babywise right from the start and it really seems to work for them. I wasn't up for the CIO. I just looked at all the literature out there as food for thought and took what I thought was useful (I do think somepeople seem to get overly obsessive with schedules and routines). I don't think any of the methods would advocate not feeding your baby if she's hungry and not putting her down for a nap if she's tierd. Good luck! They'll only be babies for such a short period of time so we might as well enjoy it..the crazyiness can only last for so long afterall. =)

Aaron & Cassie May 28, 2010 at 12:41 PM  

I've been reading your blog forever, it seems and love it. I have an almost-3 year old and a 9 month old. I found out about Dr Weissbluth's book, "Healthy Sleep Habits, Healthy Child" when my oldest was about a year. It has seriously done miracles for both of my kids. We don't follow it to a tee, but he shows how you set a schedule around your child's needs. This means helping your child learn how to fall asleep on their own (doing a routine around naptimes, etc). I'm a work-from-home-mom for 20-35 hours a week. It's doable, but I agree: you'll need some sort of predictability. My son was easy peasy, but my daughter, my second child, is a bit more stubborn. But, she's on a lovely schedule now it and it works for us.

Variations On A Theme May 28, 2010 at 2:44 PM  

I was an obnoxious anti-Babywise evangelist when my daughter was a baby. When she was born, I knew at least six women who were adament Babywise advocates. (The book is called "Growing Kids God's Way" in Christian circles.)

Everything they told me seemed intuitively wrong. (Like her brain wouldn't develop properly if she didn't get eight straight hours of sleep at night. The girl is nine now and highly gifted. She didn't start sleeping through the night until she was well over a year old. When my daughter was two months old, one woman told me that I was setting my girl up for eating disorders later in life. "I've struggled with weight all my life, so I know," said the rather large woman. I was getting really pissed off by this point, because she'd been telling me other ridiculous ways to raise my baby. As a person with a high metabolism, I responded rather rudely in order to defend my practice of feeding my baby when she was hungry: "Well, I don't have a problem with my weight, and I eat whatever and whenever I want."

So I started researching. Turns out the American Academy of Pediatrics issued a warning about the book, because so many babies were coming in for appointments with "failure to thrive." http://aapnews.aappublications.org/cgi/content/abstract/14/4/21

Also, "Dr." Ezzo is not a doctor. So much scary information. So many bizarre recommendations - like when your baby starts eating solid food, you're supposed to slap her hand and saying "hands down!" if she tries to touch her food when you're feeding her, because she's not "responsible enough" to not make a mess.

Also, you're not supposed to tell your children about sex until the night before their wedding. Those are the later books, of course. Having read all the books, I could list a hundred things here.

Ezzo compares his program with the AAP and claims it's within the guidelines, but the AAP refutes this claim: http://www.ezzo.info/Aney/aapsummary.pdf

Here's more scary info: http://www.nospank.net/granju2.htm
http://www.ezzo.info/Aney/tulsakidspart1.pdf

Sorry to be so long-winded. I get wound up about this topic.

Nine Months to Life May 28, 2010 at 8:42 PM  

Wow. That is scary. Thanks so much for sharing all of that.

Anonymous,  May 31, 2010 at 12:32 PM  

To hell with schedules!

-Aubrey

Post a Comment

  © Blogger template Simple n' Sweet by Ourblogtemplates.com 2009

Back to TOP